In the quiet rural outskirts of Tucson, Arizona, what started as an act of holiday goodwill turned into a nightmare on December 23, 2024. Paul Clifford, a 53-year-old devoted husband, father, and karate black belt, was awakened by a knock at his door around 11:30 p.m. A stranger claimed his car had broken down in the remote area near San Pedro River Road, pleading for help. True to his compassionate nature, Clifford, dressed in pajama pants, grabbed his daughter’s white Ford Ranger and drove off to assist, assuring his family he’d handle it.
The Mystery
Hours passed without his return. His daughter, Sabrina Vining, tracked the truck via GPS to rugged Redington Pass, a desolate trail between the Catalina and Rincon Mountains. Alarmed, the family reported him missing. Pima County Sheriff’s deputies initially treated it as a vehicle theft but soon discovered Clifford’s body—shot and set ablaze—next to a smoldering stolen GMC Sierra. The Ford was recovered at a midtown Tucson apartment complex.
Nearly a week later, on December 30, a SWAT standoff led to the arrests of Jack Upchurch, 40, a repeat offender with a history of theft and weapons charges; Elmer Smith, 19; and Wendy Scott, 16. Indicted on charges including first-degree murder, armed robbery, and kidnapping, the trio preyed on Clifford’s kindness in a calculated scheme.
Today
As of July 2025, controversial plea deals have sparked outrage: Smith offered one year in prison, Scott probation, while Upchurch faces full trial for murder. Clifford’s widow, Christina, calls it “a punch to the gut,” fearing for safety and pushing for justice.fox10phoenix.com Sheriff Chris Nanos warns,
“The world isn’t the same anymore.”
This heartbreaking story of betrayed empathy leaves lingering questions about motives and leniency. For the full chilling details, including family interviews and crime scene insights, watch our video. Support the Cliffords via their GoFundMe and remember: Kindness can be costly—stay vigilant.
Leave a Reply